I'm picking Edge. I don't see Shadow being able to steal, use ninjutsu(he has to use SCROLLS, HE CAN'T DO IT BY HIMSELF), AND dual-wield without the use of a relic. Plus, Edge manages to get in a humorous scene here and there, while Shadow is too serious to even think of such things.
![[Image: 2mfE19.gif]](http://cdn.makeagif.com/media/10-30-2014/2mfE19.gif)