MML challenge: Within the Giant

It's time for the battle of the Giants!

Vote for your favorite version and tell us why you prefer this version of this FF4 classic!

Royaken's version                            Gi Nattak's version

It's better Gi Nattak even this time, but the gap was smaller this time, at least for my ears...

They are very similar, forged from the same midi I'm sure. Playing them over each other proves this lol. So this battle's probably more about volume levels, panning and drum selection this time, as opposed to the last two that were drastically different.

lol, i played them over each other for real, when i tried to choose the better

very tough call but I gotta go with nattak on this one

No one seems to like my hard snare anymore xD

Sorry Royaken, your version is awesome, but you're still up against Nattak. XD

yeah, we've grown pretty fond of you here Royaken and we love ya bro, but Lockirby2 hit the nail on the head, Nattak is too much of a beast when it comes to music lol

he officially became that guy, like yeah lol

Uhmm... i heard that also Tsushiy is skilled at doing music, what would happen in the case of a Tsushiy Vs. Gi Nattak?

The way Tsushiy does his music hacks is the manual, much more tedious and complicated way, as opposed to the MML method that uses a midi and can convert data over super fast -- not to say the MML way is easy by any means, but compared to the way Tsushiy does it, it is. I consider Tsushiy the best due to this and he should get bonus points for that. He is the guy I go to when I need a music hack I can't do or need help!

I'd be fine with him participating in the challenge though if he would like to. Then it would become the music hacking challenge instead of just MML. =)

I'm already looking forward to the next challenge though, this one was more of a filler until Royaken's baby grows up...jk. Maybe just whenever he can find some spare time!