Final Requests for Help

Have you considered making tool breaks a temporary in-battle effect?

Not really, no. I'm happy with the way it is. 1 in 32 is not actually that high. It still makes Tools WAY better than Throw. As long as you're mixing up Edgar's moves between Attack and Tools, it shouldn't happen very often. Plus, you can just buy extra tools if you're headed into a long dungeon, since I removed the 1-tool limit. In his scenario, there are a couple of merchants along the way that will sell you tools if you need them.