What sprite should I make next?

Looks good! Maybe you should make toad smaller? Just a little suggestion

yeah I agree a small toad would be better

I agree with the both of you.. but not sure where to go and how many pixels to remove. I can make his hat smaller, make his legs shorter, or make his body shorter.. or a combination of it all. Let me know if you got a good idea of where I can shave pixels or how many pixels so he doesn't look funny haha. As of now his hat is 8pixels high making him appear taller. hmmmm