11-22-2012, 08:32 PM
Generally nice idea but Well I have to be fair i think the rate part is not rly working out unless we strictly rate based on technicalities only, which is extremely hard. Music is way too subjective, unless a remix is technically complete trash I would never rate below 8 since it feels rude considering its just personal opinion and nothing more. Its like i never press the dislike button on YT for music. If i dont like a track i dont rate.
Example: Im not only not a fan of chiptunes I also think, like with 90% of vgm music remixes, the original frog theme is just way better (imo usually only arrangements and masterings will improve vgm music, and unless and orchestra plays it which btw is rather arrangement than remix, not even instrumental covers do much good.). Alrdy feel bad saying that and normally wouldnt have, just did it to underline my point. From a tchnical point of view I guess its good work but I think its pointless ot rate the technical part on music, since only the emotion it creates counts. I wont give you a number.
Example: Im not only not a fan of chiptunes I also think, like with 90% of vgm music remixes, the original frog theme is just way better (imo usually only arrangements and masterings will improve vgm music, and unless and orchestra plays it which btw is rather arrangement than remix, not even instrumental covers do much good.). Alrdy feel bad saying that and normally wouldnt have, just did it to underline my point. From a tchnical point of view I guess its good work but I think its pointless ot rate the technical part on music, since only the emotion it creates counts. I wont give you a number.